Sign up for Medicare in Willow Street, PA
Local licensed agents in Lancaster County are available to assist you if you need help comparing plans or registering for Medicare insurance.
Original Medicare
Original Medicare (Part A) covers most medically necessary services.
Medicare Supplement
Medigap plans provide additional insurance for out of pocket costs.
Medicare Advantage
A bundled alternative to Original Medicare for your health and drug coverage.
Not sure what Medicare plan is right for you?
Willow Street, PA Medicare Supplement Insurance Plan Comparison
First, decide between Traditional Medicare (which covers Parts A and B) and a private insurance's Medicare Advantage (known as Part C). If you go with Traditional Medicare, you'll probably also need a Medigap insurance to cover extra costs and a Part D plan for prescription drugs.
Medicare Advantage Plans: Age 65, Zipcode 17584, Non-smoker*
| Plan Type | Number of Plans Available | Average Monthly Premium | Lowest Monthly Premium | Highest Monthly Premium | Carriers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $0 OOP Medicare Advantage Plans | 90 | $0.00 | $0.00 | $0.00 | Aetna Medicare, Humana, UPMC for Life |
| Paid Medicare Advantage Plans | 36 | $65.64 | $3.90 | $262.30 | Aetna Medicare, UPMC for Life, Humana |
*Plan data last updated on 1/15/2026
Most Popular Medigap Plans: Female, Age 65, Zipcode 17584, Non-smoker*
| Plan Type | Number of Plans Available | Average Monthly Premium | Lowest Monthly Premium | Highest Monthly Premium | Carriers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan F | 32 | $198.29 | $129.68 | $328.49 | Physicians Select, Insurance Company of North America, State Farm, and 29 others |
| Plan G | 32 | $158.53 | $104.88 | $244.23 | Physicians Select, Insurance Company of North America, State Farm, and 29 others |
| Plan N | 32 | $117.68 | $84.23 | $175.00 | Insurance Company of North America, State Farm, Wisconsin Physicians Service, and 29 others |
*Plan data last updated on 1/15/2026
Most Popular Medigap Plans: Male, Age 65, Zipcode 17584, Non-smoker*
| Plan Type | Number of Plans Available | Average Monthly Premium | Lowest Monthly Premium | Highest Monthly Premium | Carriers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan F | 32 | $220.67 | $149.13 | $377.79 | Physicians Select, Insurance Company of North America, State Farm, and 29 others |
| Plan G | 32 | $177.82 | $115.95 | $280.89 | Physicians Select, Insurance Company of North America, State Farm, and 29 others |
| Plan N | 32 | $131.50 | $94.61 | $201.00 | Insurance Company of North America, State Farm, Wisconsin Physicians Service, and 29 others |
*Plan data last updated on 1/15/2026
Disclaimer: The information provided in these tables is for general informational purposes only. We make no guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of the data. Please consult with a professional advisor or insurance provider for precise and up-to-date information.
Need help? Speak to a licensed Medicare insurance agent in Willow Street today

Angela Erickson
Licensed Medicare Agent
Contact Angela through Medicare Agents Hub »
Willow Street, PA Medicare Resource Center
Willow Street Medicare Information
If you're looking to sign up for Medicare in Willow Street, PA, MedicareSignups.com can be your go-to resource. Our plan comparison tool makes it easy to explore different Medicare plans, helping you find one that suits your unique needs. Remember, while Medicare is a national program, your plan choices are local and can vary by state and even by zip code. Interestingly, Willow Street is home to Hans Herr House, the oldest surviving homestead in Lancaster County, built in 1719. Whether you're turning 65 or are a current Medicare beneficiary, use MedicareSignups.com to navigate your Medicare options in Willow Street.
Willow Street, PA Local Medicare Offices
Pennsylvania Official State Health Insurance Assistant Program
Pennsylvania's official state SHIP program is the Pennsylvania Department of Aging. Pennsylvania Medicare Education and Decision Insight (PA MEDI) offers free Medicare counseling to older Pennsylvanians. PA MEDI Counselors are specially trained to answer your questions and provide you with objective, easy-to-understand information about Medicare, Medicare Supplemental Insurance, Medicaid, and Long-Term Care Insurance.





